Friday, January 29, 2021

What Unites Us: Reflections on Patriotism by Dan Rather & Elliot Kirschner

★★★★★

Years ago, I associated Dan Rather mostly with this crazy quote I remember hearing him say in real time on the news during the 2000 election: “This race is as tight as a too-small bathing suit on a too-hot car ride back from the beach.”

In more recent years, I know him for his level-headed, poignant, and inspiring posts on social media.

This book is part memoir, part history lesson, and part commentary. Each chapter is an essay on an institution or idea upon which democracy depends and which we as patriots must defend. The tone is conversational, frequently nostalgic, and generally uplifting. Mr. Rather covers a wide range of topics, from obvious principles such as voting rights and freedom of the press to more foundational concepts such as belief in science, pursuit of knowledge and art, and preservation of the environment. In his own life spanning more than 80 years, and in his role as a journalist, Mr. Rather truly had a front-row seat to history, which he outlines in broad strokes as he recounts his personal role in specific events. 

As a liberal progressive, I frequently found myself thinking that Mr. Rather was clearly writing about what unites Democrats. Are conservative Republicans also reading this book, hoping to see the potential for a more unified country? I hope they, too, agree that "building tolerance is a worthy way station to a much grander destination of inclusion." (p. 74) It was certainly encouraging to be reminded of times past when our leaders were not so polarized, for example, when President Reagan expressed support for amnesty for undocumented immigrants. (p. 119)

I appreciate that, when addressing some of the darker times of our national history, instead of trying to insist that "this isn't who we are," as many often do, Mr. Rather says, "This is not good enough; we can be better." (p. 17) He stops short of saying that we, as a nation, are defined by the worst of us, but at least he acknowledges that our nation is flawed, and we are on an endless mission to do better. 

There is nothing earth-shatteringly insightful in this book, but it is a timely publication, written after the 2016 election. Having read this book in the days surrounding President Biden's inauguration, I actually feel optimistic again. What Unites Us is both a balm for the soul in unsettling times and a call to action to continually work to improve our nation.   

Sunday, January 10, 2021

Keeper of the Lost Cities Roundup

An immersive fantasy world reminiscent of Harry Potter but with an exciting enough story arc to keep it feeling different.

Flashback (Keeper of the Lost Cities #7) by Shannon Messenger

★★½

*** Warning: This review contains spoilers!! ***

Early on in the series, when I read one book after another, I complained that there was too much recap at the beginning of each book. Now that I'm picking up book 7 after a long hiatus, I can't remember anything, and I need all the recap I can get! Still, it's not enough, there are so many references to things I don't remember at all. Oh, well.

I feel a little bad about my relatively low rating of this book, but it was just too long, with too much dialog that felt like filler, and not enough action. The book started out promising, but then fizzled, and I was halfway through before I felt like things started happening again. As in other books in the series, the storytelling that moved events forward continued to feel sloppy, with everyone mostly guessing at what the evildoers' plans were, then landing on a theory with a declaration of, "That makes sense."

I really enjoyed the creation of the multi-species bodyguard team; I liked the idea of all the species working together.

I didn't enjoy the additional focus on the Fitz-Sophie-Keefe love triangle; I'm just not a fan of romance being tangled up in action stories. Sophie still strikes me as "young", like a teenybopper compared to Fitz and Keefe being more in the "older teenager" category. I am not sure what is so desirable about Sophie to make her the target of everyone's affection, except that she's the moonlark, which makes her mysterious and special. I think both Biana and Linh having admirers would be more believable. Anyway, as eye-rolling as this sub-plot is to me, I was glad to finally see movement in the story line, and a resolution. And given how I think of Sophie as "young", I was pleased to see her put the brakes on moving too fast with Fitz. She may have been unbelievably oblivious to Fitz's feelings for her, but she was remarkably aware and mature in understanding her own feelings for Fitz, and recognizing that she wasn't really ready for a relationship yet. Wow! I super appreciated the good modeling for young readers.

Events finally picked up towards the end of the book, and the plot developments - particularly those including Alvar and "the Vacker legacy" - did not disappoint! In my mind, the ending lifted the book to 2 1/2 stars. Not sure if I will continue the series, but I'm not ruling it out.